Scientists conduct randomized trial to assess e-cigarette versus traditional cigarette use

Reviewed by Emily Henderson, B.Sc.

 

Scientists and medical professionals have long debated whether pod e-cigarettes are a safer alternative to traditional cigarettes. A new study provides some insight.

In a collaboration between The University of Kansas Cancer Center, California State University San Marcos and Brown University, scientists conducted a six-week-long randomized trial comparing e-cigarette use to traditional cigarette use in African American and Latinx smokers. E-cigarettes simulate tobacco smoke via battery-powered devices that work by heating a liquid into a vapor that the user inhales.

Nikki Nollen, PhD, co-program leader of KU Cancer Center’s Cancer Prevention and Control research program, served as site principal investigator.

“Fourth generation e-cigarettes contain high concentrations of nicotine and other appealing features that may support switching and reduce potential health risks among those who smoke combustible cigarettes,” Dr. Nollen said. “We wanted to examine the biomarkers of exposure in both groups and determine the risk-benefit tradeoff of e-cigarettes.”

Those who switched to e-cigarettes experienced a significant reduction in a certain biomarker called NNAL. When NNK, a tobacco-specific lung carcinogen is metabolized, it converts to NNAL, indicating the body’s exposure to tobacco products. E-cigarette users also experienced a dramatic drop in carbon monoxide and self-reported respiratory symptoms. Nicotine exposure, lung function and blood pressure remained unchanged.

“What was most surprising was the magnitude of change experienced by those in the e-cigarette group,” Dr. Nollen said. “They reduced their NNAL by 64%, carbon monoxide by 47% and respiratory symptoms by 37% compared to those in the control group who continued to smoke cigarettes as usual.”

Dr. Nollen and the team were also surprised to witness that a complete switch to e-cigarettes was not needed to achieve benefits. Those in the e-cigarette group who only partially switched – i.e., became dual users of both cigarettes and e-cigarettes – also experienced reductions in NNAL, carbon monoxide and respiratory symptoms, though to a lesser degree than those who made a complete switch.

The findings of the clinical study – the first such trial to examine fourth-generation salt-based nicotine e-cigarettes – were published in JAMA Network Open.

Improving disparities

To recruit participants for the study, Dr. Nollen and her team leaned on a 20-year partnership with Swope Health Services Central, a federally qualified health center located in Kansas City, Missouri. More than 85% of Swope’s patient population is African American. KU Cancer Center members have teamed up with Swope on 10 studies over the last two decades.

Overall, African Americans and Latinxs tend to smoke less compared to other ethnicities, but they are more likely to develop and die from tobacco-related health issues.

The two minorities have largely been underrepresented in e-cigarette studies. Excluding these groups from such studies only worsens the uneven burden of tobacco-related deaths and disease they experience.

According to Dr. Nollen, longer studies must be conducted in order to understand the long-term effects of e-cigarettes, but this study may serve as a springboard for additional research endeavors.

“Quitting cigarettes is the priority. But for those unwilling or unable, our findings support using e-cigarettes as a harm reduction strategy for African American and Latinx smokers who experience significant tobacco-related health disparities.”
-Nikki Nollen, PhD, Site Principal Investigator and Co-Program Leader, Cancer Prevention and Control Research Program, University of Kansas Cancer Center

Source:
Journal reference:

Pulvers, K., et al. (2020) Effect of Pod e-Cigarettes vs Cigarettes on Carcinogen Exposure Among African American and Latinx Smokers A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Network Open..doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.26324.

(This article first appeared here.)

 

Share:FacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmailFacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Translate

Follow WordPress.com on WordPress.com

Follow Us

FacebooktwitterpinterestyoutubetumblrinstagramFacebooktwitterpinterestyoutubetumblrinstagram

Recent Comments

Donate via PayPal

Donate Via Patreon

Twitter Feed

Tuesday, January 5th, 2021 at 8:19am
To all of you who may have commented on the site, sorry if your message was mistakenly flagged as 'spam'... I have way too much #spam to deal with ! This is with Captcha enabled, too. https://t.co/uACsMSlKJK TheVaporNinja photo
Wednesday, December 23rd, 2020 at 5:13pm
PROTECT #vape MAIL!
ALL VAPING ACCESS THREATENED IN PROPOSED BILL.
TAKE ACTION AT @CASAAmedia !
https://t.co/PXcZt5Druf
Thursday, December 17th, 2020 at 11:59am
@Vapingit @DrTomFrieden YES indeed #vaping has helped literally millions of humans quit the dreaded #tobacco . It should be lauded as one the most beneficial technologies of this century. Encouraged, government subsidized, and normalized. The CDC has been mired in problems for years. Time for reform.
Saturday, December 12th, 2020 at 10:33pm
Hey, participate, make your voice HEARD. Include your story about why flavors help you stay off of #tobacco ! I know they help ME stay off of the stinkies ! #vape on ! https://t.co/EQPR0so9Rm
TheVaporNinja photo
CASAA @CASAAmedia
2020 VAPE CONSUMER SURVEY: The annual eCigIntelligence survey, done in conjunction with CASAA, gathers and shares factual information to ensure U.S. stakeholders and policymakers better understand the TRUTH about how and why adults vape (like flavors)!

https://t.co/2cogzH4Upc https://t.co/abOyHbQxwg
Monday, November 30th, 2020 at 5:36am
Scientific trial results in showing that 'dual-use' of #ecig and #tobacco significantly reduces toxins.
https://t.co/Ncrxtjp2Ve
Saturday, October 10th, 2020 at 5:02am
@ChaunceyGardner @Dstat_THR @asthma I have COPD from my many years of tobacco abuse. I was wheezing and using inhalers. After quitting tobacco via vape technology, a few months later I was inhaler-free, symptom-free, and my doctor says my lungs sounds perfect. I was also using oxygen occasionally. Saved by the vape
Saturday, September 26th, 2020 at 4:24pm
@GrimmGreen @KatTimpf The last beef I ate was in about 1988.
You can do it too.
It's unnecessary and harmful. :)
Saturday, September 26th, 2020 at 4:16pm
Goodbye and farewell to @MendocinoVapors , they had to close shop due to being deemed 'non-essential'.
https://t.co/Koa3mL7D7z
Thursday, September 24th, 2020 at 9:44am
@ChaunceyGardner I think the period after 'cost' was a typo, they meant to say 'more cost effective'.
Thursday, September 24th, 2020 at 9:39am
@ElianaGolber Glantz.
Just seeing that name on a study should invalidate it immediately.
Saturday, September 19th, 2020 at 5:07pm
I can't believe it's been a YEAR since #India has banned vaping. #vapingsaveslives and India has a high prevalance of #tobacco use.
I hope the protests go well and make a difference. https://t.co/6jIxGIdgKk